Connecting you to the composites industry


High Court Upholds Ford Case

  • Saturday, 2nd November 2002
  • Reading time: about 2 minutes

The California Supreme Court on Wednesday let stand a $290 million verdict against the Ford Motor Co. over a deadly 1993 rollover accident involving a Ford Bronco.

The justices decided without comment not to review an appeal from the automaker, which in court papers called the verdict the nation’s largest personal injury award ever affirmed by an appeals court. The case involved a crash of a 1978 Bronco near Ceres, about 80 miles south of Sacramento, in which three members of the Romo family were killed and two others injured.

The verdict was meant to punish Ford for what an appeals court found was “despicable conduct.” The Romo family’s attorney, Joe Carcione, said Ford knew the Bronco “would crush flat as a pancake in a rollover.”

Ford attorney Theodore Boutrous Jr., echoing business interests that had urged the state’s high court to overturn the verdict, said the justices missed an opportunity to rein in runaway verdicts. “This is an extreme and unconstitutional award,” Boutrous said. “We plan to ask the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn it.”

“We think that it is obvious that putting on the market a motor vehicle with a known propensity to roll over and, while giving the vehicle the appearance of sturdiness, consciously deciding not to provide adequate crush protection to properly belted passengers constitutes despicable conduct,” Justice Steven Vartabedian wrote for the appeals court, which ruled 3-0. “Such conduct could kill people.”

The Bronco’s roof was made partially of steel and fiberglass. As the vehicle rolled, the steel collapsed, killing Ramon Romo, the passenger in the front seat. The fiberglass also broke loose, striking and killing his wife, Salustia, and his child, Ramiro. All three were wearing seat belts. Two other children not wearing seat belts were thrown from the Bronco and injured.

In its appeal, Ford said one juror was influenced by a TV news show in which lawyers alleged the automaker would rather litigate cases than correct defects. Ford also charged that another juror, during deliberations, described to fellow panelists an “omen” in which she dreamed that her child, and fellow jurors’ children, were killed by a Bronco.

The verdict could have a serious effect on Ford’s bottom line. Chairman and chief executive William Clay Ford Jr. announced plans Monday to cut $1 billion in spending after reporting a third-quarter loss of $326 million.

For more information visit:

Share this article

More News

Comments (0)

Sign in or create an account to join in the discussion.

Leave your comment


Upcoming Events




Follow us
Subscribe to our email newsletter

Subscribe to receive our weekly round-up of all the industry's latest news, jobs, events and more!

We'll always keep your personal details secure and will never share them with third parties for marketing purposes. You can unsubscribe at any time. For further details on how we may use your data, please visit our Privacy Policy.